Quick answer
Picture this: it's 6 p.m. on a Tuesday, you're heading home from work on Yonge Street, and you walk out to the driveway the next morning to find an empty spot where your car used to be. It's a gut punch, and it's the reason many Richmond Hill drivers ask about theft coverage. The good news is that car theft is falling in York Region, with reported thefts down 36% in 2025. Western Financial Group sees that it still affects what Richmond Hill drivers pay for car insurance. If your car is stolen, optional comprehensive or all-perils coverage pays for it, minus your deductible (the part you pay first). Driving a frequently stolen model, like a Honda CR-V or Lexus RX, can raise your premium, and some insurers may ask for an anti-theft device before they'll cover it. Here's what you need to know, in plain language.
How common is car theft in York Region?
Auto theft has dropped sharply since its peak, but it hasn't gone away. According to York Regional Police's 2025 annual statistics:
- Vehicle thefts: 2,057 in 2025, down 36% from 3,226 in 2024.
- Attempted thefts: 350 in 2025, down 41%.
- Carjackings: 37 in 2025, down 54% from 81 in 2024.
Across Ontario, auto thefts fell 22% in 2025 compared with 2024, according to Équité Association, which tracks insurance crime in Canada. Nationally, thefts dropped 18%. Think of it this way: fewer cars are disappearing from driveways than a couple of years ago, but it's still a real risk for your neighbours and maybe for you.
Which cars are stolen most in Ontario?
Équité Association's 2025 list of Ontario's most stolen vehicles includes:
- Honda CR-V (the most stolen vehicle in Ontario and Canada)
- Honda Civic
- Lexus RX Series
- Toyota Tundra
- Toyota RAV4
Think of a family SUV parked on the street overnight: it's exactly the kind of vehicle thieves look for. Newer SUVs and trucks are frequent targets because they're in demand for export. Find out more about the most popular cars for thieves.
How does car theft affect insurance in Richmond Hill?
Insurers price theft risk in a few ways:
- Your vehicle: Frequently stolen models usually cost more to insure, since insurers expect more theft claims.
- Where you live and park: Local theft rates and whether you park in a private garage can both play a role.
- Anti-theft requirements: Some insurers may ask for an approved tracking device or immobilizer on high-theft vehicles before offering comprehensive coverage.
- Your claims history: A theft claim can affect your premium at renewal, depending on your insurer.
If two neighbours on the same street each have a vehicle (one drives a Honda CR-V and the other a small, rarely stolen hatchback), the CR-V owner will often pay more, because insurers expect more theft claims on that model. The good news is that falling theft numbers may ease some of that pressure over time. For a closer look at how theft affects prices in another GTA community, read how vehicle theft affects Scarborough car insurance.
Does car insurance cover a stolen car in Ontario?
Only if you have the right optional coverage:
- Comprehensive or all-perils coverage: Covers theft of your vehicle and damage from a break-in or attempted theft.
- Specified perils coverage: Covers theft as a named peril.
- Mandatory coverage alone: Doesn't cover theft of your own vehicle.
Here's a common surprise: if a thief breaks your window and takes the laptop from your back seat, you'd claim the window on your car policy, but the laptop on your home or tenant policy. Items stolen from inside your car, like a laptop or gym bag, are usually covered by your home or tenant insurance rather than your car policy. Learn more about why comprehensive coverage matters for theft, and what happens if your car is stolen with the keys inside.
Driving a high-theft vehicle? Get a free, no-obligation quote and a Richmond Hill broker will find insurers that fit your car and your budget.
How to protect your car and lower your premium
- Park in a locked garage whenever you can.
- Install an approved anti-theft device, such as a tracking system or immobilizer. Some insurers offer a discount.
- Protect your key fob. Store it in a signal-blocking pouch, away from doors and windows, to help prevent relay attacks.
- Use a steering wheel lock or port lock as a visible deterrent.
- Never leave your car running unattended, even for a minute.
- Keep valuables out of sight.
Small habits really do add up. Something as simple as moving your key fob from the front hall table to a signal-blocking pouch in a drawer can make a thief's job much harder. More tips: can anti-theft devices lower your car insurance?
What changed in Ontario car insurance in 2026?
In plain terms: you now choose how much injury protection to carry, instead of getting it all automatically. Since July 1, 2026, most Ontario accident benefits, including income replacement and non-earner benefits, are optional instead of included in every policy. Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits are still mandatory, according to the Insurance Bureau of Canada. If you're reviewing your policy because of theft concerns, it's a good time to check these choices too. Read our guide to Ontario's 2026 auto insurance reforms.
What to do if your car is stolen
- Call police to report the theft and get a report number.
- Contact your broker or insurer as soon as possible.
- Gather your documents, including your ownership, keys and any tracking device details.
- Ask about a rental. Loss of use coverage, if you have it, can help pay for a rental car.
How a broker like Western Financial Group can help
Think of a Western broker in Richmond Hill as a friendly second set of eyes on your policy. Insurers treat high-theft vehicles differently: some charge more, some require anti-theft devices and some offer discounts for them. A Western broker can compare options from several insurers, explain any device requirements in plain language, and help you find the best price for your car. If your vehicle is stolen, your broker can guide you through the claim and stay with you every step of the way.
It also helps to know who you're dealing with. Western Financial Group has protected more than one million Canadians and holds an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), which means customers can trust us to do right by them. In 2026, we also won a Canadian Business Excellence Award for Private Businesses and were named one of Insurance Business Canada's Top Insurance Employers. That means a lot to us, because it reflects the people who answer your calls and help you through a claim.
Giving back matters to us, too. The Western Communities Foundation, our charitable arm, has spent the past 25 years helping Canadian communities, from York Region neighbourhoods to towns coast to coast. Through community grants, employee giving, volunteer time, bursaries and emergency relief, the Foundation supports charities and the people they serve. It might be a bursary that eases the cost of a student's first year, or help for a community recovering from a disaster. Either way, we're proud that our team and our clients are part of it.
Richmond Hill car theft insurance FAQs
Is car theft still a problem in Richmond Hill?
It's improving. York Regional Police reported 2,057 vehicle thefts in 2025, down 36% from 2024, but theft remains a factor in local insurance pricing.
Does insurance cover my car if it's stolen?
Yes, if you carry comprehensive, all-perils or specified perils coverage. Mandatory coverage alone doesn't cover theft.
Will my insurance go up if I drive a Honda CR-V?
It may cost more to insure, since it was Ontario's most stolen vehicle in 2025. Prices vary by insurer, so compare options.
Can anti-theft devices lower my car insurance?
Some insurers offer discounts for approved tracking systems or immobilizers, and some may require them for high-theft vehicles.
Are items stolen from my car covered?
Personal items stolen from your car are usually covered by your home or tenant insurance, not your car policy.
Will a theft claim raise my premium?
Theft is generally not an at-fault claim, but it can still affect your premium depending on your insurer and claims history.
Talk to a local Western broker
Western Financial Group's Richmond Hill brokers can help you protect your car and find the right coverage. Learn more about car insurance in Richmond Hill.
This article is general information only and isn't insurance, legal or financial advice. Coverage depends on your insurer and the wording of your policy. Talk to a licensed broker about your situation.
